PDA

View Full Version : [The Coggies] Gaming News Story of the Year


DoctorFinger
12-09-2008, 07:55 AM
Gaming News Story of the Year

Vivendi and Activision merge to become Activision Blizzard - Did you know that Electronic Arts is no longer the largest game publisher in the world? Did you know that they lost the crown to Activision even before they merged with Vivendi to form Activision Blizzard? Whatever the case, A-B is still the biggest dog on the block, and in the process they seem to have also taken the crown of 'most reviled' company in gaming. Add to that the 800-pound gorilla known as Blizzard - you may have heard of one of their products, World of Warcraft - and you get a single entity most capable of turning the rudder of the industry. Activision Blizzard CEO Bobby Kotick now knows what it's like to be on top after numerous incidents in which quotes made by him were pushed to the forefront by the games press and either greatly embraced or roundly ridiculed by gamers.

"The Year of the Casual Gamer" - To me the 'moment of the year' occurred during Nintendo's E3 press conference. For the better part of a hour I - along with innumerable other gamers - sat at my computer as a parade of so-called 'casual' games were trotted out by Nintendo's brain trust. But I kept watching, anticipating that Nintendo would come through for us 'core' gamers. Would it be a new Kid Icarus? A peek at the next Zelda? Could there be some other franchise, some other property, the Big N could whip out of the archives and unleash upon the Wii owning public. We ended up with Wii Music and a whole lotta nothing. This more than anything cemented 2008 as the year that casual gaming moved to the fore, possibly to the detriment of 'core' gaming. Increasingly publishers are pushing titles aimed not at 20-35 year old males, instead unleashing waves of games centered around karaoke, yoga, and instrument playing designed to appeal to all of the other demographics out there. And the class of gamer who had previously been the sole paramour of the industry is beginning to feel - right or wrong - like a spurned lover.

Ensemble Studios to Close after Halo Wars - A lot of console gamers weren't too familiar with the name Ensemble studios, creators of PC-centric strategy fare like Age of Empires, but even the console crowd was taken aback by the announcement that Microsoft would be shuttering the studio after they complete work on the RTS Halo Wars. Nearly a year before the game even ships, and the death mark is on the development house. In a year in which a number of studios and houses went under, this was the most shocking.

Itagaki's divorce from Tecmo - Tomonobu Itagaki was a rock star. The flamboyant head of Tecmo's Team Ninja was super cool force behind the Ninja Gaiden and Dead or Alive franchises, and was one of the more well known developers in the industry. Which makes his acrimonious exit from Tecmo earlier this year all the more fascinating. The details of the divorce are still somewhat nebulous. Here's what we know. Itagaki and Tecmo were sued over allegations of sexual harassment at the workplace. Itagaki denied the allegations, at one point reportedly denigrating his accuser in earshot of a reporter, and on the surface life moved on, including the launch of Ninja Gaiden 2. But behind the scenes, things were more complex. While a court eventually found Itagaki not guilty of actual harassment, Tecmo was reportedly upset with his treatment of their employees, especially the female ones, allegations they leaked to the press. Itagaki was also angry that a bonus he felt he was obligated to receive had not yet materialized. Combine that with what he felt were disrespectful statements made by Tecmo president Yoshimi Yasuda and the damage was done. Just days before Ninja Gaiden 2 launched, Itagaki quit Tecmo, and in the process filed suit to recover the money he's felt he's owed. What does this mean for Team Ninja's two marquee properties? Tecmo will undoubtedly go forward with them, but will gamers feel the same way about them without the flamboyant Itagaki at the helm?

Final Fantasy XIII announced as multiplatform - Final Fantasy XIII heading to the Xbox 360 was the dream - or sometimes the nightmare - of fanboys across the world. When Microsoft announced at the climax of their E3 address that Square Enix' cash cow would be coming to the 360, the reaction was immediate, and entertainingly explosive. While industry watchers expected it eventually, the revelation was still huge. We've known for a long time that third-party exclusives were an endangered species, and this was just confirmation of that trend. A tangent to this story is the tale of Bungie's Halo: ODST. It was supposed to be announced at MS' E3 presser, and Bungie was even teasing something huge. Then, nothing. Microsoft forced Bungie to hold off on the announcement (until September's TGS) rather than possibly blunt the Final Fantasy XIII announcement.

Bungie's split from Microsoft - The story many of us thought would never, could never, happen. Bungie, the studio responsible for the Xbox' biggest cash cow, Halo, splitting from Microsoft. The split was mostly amicable - Bungie will still be working on Halo games for at least a little while longer - but the people at Bungie were clearly worried that they'd be working on nothing but Halo until the end of time if they didn't act when they did. The whole E3-Halo: ODST kerfuffle didn't help matters too much, but releations between Bungie and Microsoft are still said to be pretty good. At least they will be until Bungie announced their first Playstation game...

civil
12-09-2008, 08:01 AM
FF XIII. I don't think anything else was able to pry gamers' pudgy hands off of their Cheetos bag an onto the keyboard as much as this story.

pheriannath
12-09-2008, 08:01 AM
Wasn't the Bungie split in 2007?

Karmakin
12-09-2008, 08:02 AM
FFXIII for sure I think.

menage
12-09-2008, 08:09 AM
Voted FFXIII as well
Just because it was probably the only thing about E3 which was really noteworthy.

Ghost Rider
12-09-2008, 08:15 AM
FF XIII. I didn't expect it, but the more people that can (or have to option to) experience a game the better.

Commissar Rob
12-09-2008, 08:26 AM
What Nintendo has done with the Wii and the type of gaming the Wii represents, as well as the broader impact of the "casual" genre as a whole, really feels like the biggest story and trend this year to me. Sometimes, it seems like the casual movement is something of an 800 pound gorilla we just don't want to pay attention to. We we discuss console sales, for example, we tend to look at the 360 vs. PS3 race. Granted, we acknowledge the Wii...but more in the vein of "if we don't look at Nintendo..."

Do casual gamers buy used? Is it easier to sell VC, Arcade and PSN titles to casuals? Are they a better, more reliable source of revenue? What, if anything, does that mean to core gamers?

Wraith
12-09-2008, 08:51 AM
FFXIII on 360, because of what it represents.

The Playstation brand is no longer the clear console market leader.
It costs a lot to make current-gen games while trying to stay ahead of the curve technologically. Increasing the potential market for big budget titles is more important than ever.
Square Enix, an RPG giant, is no longer sticking to one platform for their console games. FFXIII wasn't the first (see Crystal Chronicles on the GC, The Last Remnant, among others), but it's certainly the biggest title.

Psykoboy2
12-09-2008, 09:06 AM
FFXIII on 360, because of what it represents.

The Playstation brand is no longer the clear console market leader.
It costs a lot to make current-gen games while trying to stay ahead of the curve technologically. Increasing the potential market for big budget titles is more important than ever.
Square Enix, an RPG giant, is no longer sticking to one platform for their console games. FFXIII wasn't the first (see Crystal Chronicles on the GC, The Last Remnant, among others), but it's certainly the biggest title.


I agree with you on all of those points, but I think the biggest thing to remember about this news story was that FFXIII was originally shown and touted as a PS3 exclusive way back when it was shown off a year or so ago.

Wraith
12-09-2008, 09:09 AM
I agree with you on all of those points, but I think the biggest thing to remember about this news story was that FFXIII was originally shown and touted as a PS3 exclusive way back when it was shown off a year or so ago.Yeah, another bullet should have been "Former PS3 exclusives going multiplatform with 360 version." Another point where FFXIII was not the first, but probably the most significant game where PS3 lost exclusivity.

Purple Santa
12-09-2008, 09:34 AM
FF XIII. I don't think anything else was able to pry gamers' pudgy hands off of their Cheetos bag an onto the keyboard as much as this story.

My Cheeto coverd hands agree :D

Telefrog
12-09-2008, 09:41 AM
What about the Spore DRM controversy? Spore's DRM wasn't the worst or the first, but I think it really put DRM in the mainstream spotlight for a bit and really illustrated how ridiculous it's getting in the industry.

Hexxagonal
12-09-2008, 09:50 AM
I went with Ensemble because who would think that a studio that seems to be operating in profit would be closed.

Wackman3000
12-09-2008, 09:59 AM
I went with Itagaki's divorce from Tecmo mostly because it seemed all rockstar-ish and one of the only tidbits of news I actually found interesting. Way to fight the man Itagaki! Now give us a good Dead of Alive game again please, preferably on the PS3.

Morangie
12-09-2008, 10:09 AM
We haven't had the MGS4 on 360 announcement yet. :)

bean
12-09-2008, 10:26 AM
Wasn't the Bungie split in 2007?
Maybe this is another case of the silly "must have exactly six choices" policy.

bean
12-09-2008, 10:35 AM
What Nintendo has done with the Wii and the type of gaming the Wii represents, as well as the broader impact of the "casual" genre as a whole, really feels like the biggest story and trend this year to me.
Biggest ongoing trend? Absolutely.

Biggest story? Not so much. Nintendo has been the game industry's hoola-hoop for years now. It's a good story, but there isn't enough new to it to make it that interesting. If I was writing a feature on this, the highlights would be the success of Wii Fit and how it has been highlighted in women's programming (Oprah especially) to boost sales even further and the fact that it continues to grow despite a game library that leaves many hardcore gamer's cold (and I'd quote all sides of this. . . those of us who sold our off because there weren't enough games for us, those of us who think it is a great secondary system as well as a party game device, and those who think that the first-party library is enough). So it's an interesting ongoing story and definitely belongs in this list (as a story), but the FF XIII cross-platform bit is what made Microsoft the clear winner at E3.

Hmm. . . you could even add another angle and talk about how Microsoft's poor marketing (they spend the money. . . it's just the ads are usually crap), and Sony's difficulty lowering the price of their console due to the high cost of the Blu-Ray player are keeping them from competing well with the Wii.

Libuke
12-09-2008, 10:52 AM
The first story that popped into my head was activison saying they would only publish IPs that they could "exploit", and I assume they want to exploit them annually.

I suppose I could vote for this in the merger for this story.

Commissar Rob
12-09-2008, 10:58 AM
Biggest story? Not so much. Nintendo has been the game industry's hoola-hoop for years now. It's a good story, but there isn't enough new to it to make it that interesting. So it's an interesting ongoing story and definitely belongs in this list (as a story), but the FF XIII cross-platform bit is what made Microsoft the clear winner at E3.

I guess that's where I was going when I said we have a tendency to want to ignore what's happening with the casual market. It's not particularly sexy, there aren't the over the top personalities like Itagaki or Cliffy B or such, the games don't have that "wow" factor, and I get the impression that for most gamers the Wii feels like some sort of betrayal. "What about the core gamer?"

BUT it does have the potential to have huge impacts on what games we play and how we play them (the pessimist in me says maybe not for the better). Will Sony and Microsoft put their development efforts into more of an attempt to capture the market the Wii is creating? What will that mean for PS4 or Xbox 720?

I would argue that FF XIII is big...but hardly a surprise. How many independent studios can afford to ignore the fact that neither the PS3 nor the Xbox has the sort of dominance that the PS2 did as a core gaming machine? How long until we hear the MGSIV on 360 announcement?

Kielaran
12-09-2008, 11:19 AM
My #1 was Activison-Blizzard, for the ramifications of the merger.

A close second would be Ensemble closing because it was hard to believe that they would announce the closing of a studio that far in advance who was working on such a major title, especially since the announcement would potentially turn people away who were considering picking up Halo Wars.

Wolvie
12-09-2008, 11:24 AM
I voted for the Bungie split because my brain see's Halo's creators and I go all stupid and stuff... *drool*

MagGnome
12-09-2008, 11:34 AM
None of these stories really surprised me, per se. I think the one that had the biggest impact was Vivendi's purchase/merger with Activision, making them the largest publisher and arguably one of the worst.

Stoke
12-09-2008, 12:09 PM
I went with the FFXIII story just because of how much it delighted me to watch all the whining over at Playstation forums. Some of the best entertainment I haven't paid for.

violent
12-09-2008, 12:48 PM
I went with the FFXIII story just because of how much it delighted me to watch all the whining over at Playstation forums. Some of the best entertainment I haven't paid for.

I chose FF13 as well but my gauge was just how shitty every forum became after the news.

BlackPete
12-09-2008, 02:36 PM
My vote was for Activision/Blizzard because it has a potentially huge ripple effect across the entire industry.

Although I did have to think about it because FF13 also had a huge shock value that may have caused a lot of people to change their minds about picking up a PS3. Still... it's just one game compared to a brand new Big Publisher (tm).

Disgustipated
12-09-2008, 04:03 PM
FFXIII coming to 360 was Microsoft's way of giving Sony an awesome Dirty Sanchez.

Variable Gear
12-09-2008, 09:42 PM
Maybe this is another case of the silly "must have exactly six choices" policy.
I agree, because the Microsoft/Bungie separation did occur in 2007 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bungie#Independent_company).

Come the fuck on, people. It's not too hard to find another story from 2008.

Until then, I refuse to vote on the poll. :cool:

Generation ABXY
12-09-2008, 09:53 PM
I agree, because and the Microsoft/Bungie separation did occur in 2007 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bungie#Independent_company).

Come the fuck on, people. It's not too hard to find another story from 2008.

Until then, I refuse to vote on the poll. :cool:

Damn it, that's what I get for not the whole thread first.

I have piss for memory, so I'm not surprised I didn't remember that. But, I do remember that, whenever it did happen, it came as quite the shock, at least to me. (I didn't think the multiplatform Final Fantasy was all that surprising given all the hints that seemed to be floating around.)

PathMaster
12-09-2008, 10:16 PM
Going by the criteria on what will change the industry for years to come, I personally feel the Blizzard option as being the most "game changing".

bean
12-09-2008, 11:04 PM
I agree, because the Microsoft/Bungie separation did occur in 2007 (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bungie#Independent_company).
It's not really a contender anyway. They bought themselves out to a degree but I've read that Microsoft gets a first pass on their content and it's not like Bungie is going to suddenly shift directions and start making casual games, so their content is still going to be on the Xbox 360.

There will be a loss seen by Microsoft if Halo 4 is not made for the Xbox 720 (or whatever) in 2012-2014, or if it is made by another company and the results are crap, but that's a lot of ifs for a year's distant date, and Gears of War will effectively sell systems to that demographic just as easily.

At this point in the console's life cycle, it's all about getting cheap enough for the casuals/non-core to buy your console and making tons of cash off game sales. They still need exclusives to keep interest alive (especially RPGs to continue work on the Japanese market that they need to at least soften up for the next generation). However, the Xbox 360 doesn't need a Halo 4 to sell systems.

Variable Gear
12-09-2008, 11:06 PM
It's not really a contender anyway.
If it isn't a contender, then why is it in the poll to begin with? :confused:

Generation ABXY
12-09-2008, 11:56 PM
If it isn't a contender, then why is it in the poll to begin with? :confused:

It's a trap to lure away the weak-minded; once I clicked on it, the floor fell away to a pit of spikes and killed me. True story.

Variable Gear
12-10-2008, 12:04 AM
It's a trap to lure away the weak-minded; once I clicked on it, the floor fell away to a pit of spikes and killed me. True story.
I think I heard this PSA yesterday, but you might have been asleep.

[Colonists, beware of spike pits and bottomless pits. Make sure to keep tabs on your lives as well.]

QueQueg
12-10-2008, 12:51 PM
What about Jack Thompson getting disbarred? (http://kotaku.com/5054772/jack-thompson-disbarred)

Variable Gear
12-10-2008, 01:10 PM
What about Jack Thompson getting disbarred? (http://kotaku.com/5054772/jack-thompson-disbarred)
That'd be a good stand-in for the Bungie story, which occurred last year.