PDA

View Full Version : 'Legend of the Seeker'


DoctorFinger
11-01-2008, 03:17 PM
While Georgia-Florida was in halftime, I flipped over to WGN to glance at 'Legend of the Seeker', and it's exactly what I expected.

For those out of the loop, LotS is based on Terry Goodkind's "Sword of Truth" series of fantasy novels. The first book in the series was, in my opinion, one of the best fantasy novels I've ever read. The next two were good, but the 8 (8!) after that sucked donkey balls. But even when the books stunk, the two main characters - Richard & Kahlan - were usually pretty engaging, especially when they were together.

But I digress. The little I've seen of the series is everything you'd expect from a Raimi-Tapert production. Very attractive main characters, beautiful scenery, low rent effects and acting that rarely progresses past wooden. But you don't watch a show like that for the acting, do you? The woman they got to play Kahlan - Bridget Regan - is gorgeous and spends pretty much the whole in a clingy dress. The story takes some of the core elements of the first book, but the whole thing is a bit sanitized. One of the things that made the first book so good was it's adult sensibility. At the time it was unique among the Jordans and Brooks of the world, although George Martin and other have since done it a lot better. Later books in the series confused 'adult and mature' with 'ultraviolent and sensationalistic', so in that case it may improve the material. The bit of the show I've seen so far isn't as awful as I'd feared, but it's not enough to even earn a spot on my DVR at the moment.

Spectre-7
11-01-2008, 03:34 PM
The first book in the series was, in my opinion, on of the best fantasy novels I've ever read.

Just to offer a dissenting opinion... The first book in the series was, in my opinion, one of the worst novels of any sort I've ever read. I wanted to strangle Terry Goodkind to death roughly 150 pages into it, and I only persisted through the following 700 pages out of morbid curiosity.

I may check out Legend of the Seeker, but it will doubtlessly be a home MST3K session.

Arilin
11-02-2008, 06:42 AM
So is it a series, or a TV Movie? I read the entire series in about a week and a half and I enjoyed it for what it was, so I'm curious. If it's a series, I'll have tolook at finding the episodes elsewhere as I'd like to see it from the beginning.

Nura
11-02-2008, 10:38 AM
So is it a series, or a TV Movie? I read the entire series in about a week and a half and I enjoyed it for what it was, so I'm curious. If it's a series, I'll have tolook at finding the episodes elsewhere as I'd like to see it from the beginning.

It's a series, and there's two episodes out at the moment, as far as i can tell.

Bad Buddha
11-03-2008, 09:47 AM
Have they gotten to the Bondage/Torture/Sex yet? That might be worth checking out!

I gave up after, I think, the sixth book. It seemed to drag on and on and on and on...

Sandman
11-04-2008, 12:06 PM
Finally watched it, this show gets a thumbs up for me. Never read the books. I just hope they allow character and world development beyond what has already been set.

Doctor Setebos
11-04-2008, 02:57 PM
I gave up in the fourth book. I think the first book was a good novel in and of itself. Well-paced, intriguing story, somewhat stereotypical characters, but overall a very engaging concept. The fact that the next three novels were a re-hash of the exact some ideas over and over again is what lost me.

"There's something strange going on! But Richard can't see it because he is stubborn! Oh noes!"

DoctorFinger
11-04-2008, 06:50 PM
I gave up in the fourth book. I think the first book was a good novel in and of itself. Well-paced, intriguing story, somewhat stereotypical characters, but overall a very engaging concept. The fact that the next three novels were a re-hash of the exact some ideas over and over again is what lost me.

"There's something strange going on! But Richard can't see it because he is stubborn! Oh noes!"I saw it differently. Richard always sees what's going on, but no one will ever believe him because he "doesn't know magic". So frustrating.